Could AI lead you to the wrong pension decision?

Laing Scot
Written by:

Scot Laing

19 Nov 2026

AI can answer pension questions in seconds. But when it comes to your own pension, does it really know enough about you?

AI technology has improved rapidly in the past few years and is fast becoming a central part of our professional and personal lives. It’s brilliant for learning about complex topics and gathering information, so if you want to make difficult pension decisions, AI could be your first port of call.

However, you must recognise the limitations of AI, especially when it comes to financial decisions with far-reaching consequences.

Read on to learn more about the dangers of using AI to make pension decisions.

Most AI answers are factually correct but could still lead to harmful outcomes

In the past, the major issue with AI was that it wasn’t always accurate. When these tools were first developed, they often pulled outdated information or “hallucinated” answers that were completely wrong.

While this is still a problem, the accuracy of AI has improved significantly. As such, it could be a useful tool for educating yourself about basic pension matters. For instance, you might ask it how tax relief on contributions works or what rules govern accessing a pension.

However, although AI has improved, you should still be cautious about using it to support you with pension decisions. Interesting research from PensionBee explains why.

They tested various AI tools by asking pension questions and analysing the responses. The findings showed that 89% of the answers were factually accurate.

Despite this, 11% of the answers were considered potentially harmful as they could cause somebody to lose money or make an irreversible decision that worked against them. Crucially, 58% of those harmful answers were judged to be broadly accurate or better.

This is because AI tools often delivered technically correct answers but omitted important information that should factor into decision-making. Often, you don’t know the right question to ask or all the additional factors that could affect a certain decision. AI won’t fill in these gaps, and so, even when it’s accurate, it could still suggest a course of action that is completely unsuitable for you.

There was also deviation between platforms and the type of question posed, so whether you receive a reliable answer could depend largely on luck.

Your pension is personal to you

Decisions about your pension must factor in all kinds of information about you, your lifestyle and retirement goals.

For instance, if you’re deciding whether to increase your contributions, you may think about what kind of lifestyle you want in retirement and how big your pension pot will need to be to sustain this.

Additionally, you may want to consider your current take-home pay and outgoings to see whether you can afford an increase without putting yourself in a difficult position. There might be better uses for those funds, too, such as building a cash reserve or clearing high-interest debts.

Balancing these considerations can be difficult, and you may rely on projections about your future retirement income to inform your decision-making.

An AI tool is more likely to provide generalised guidance about increasing contributions, but those recommendations may not be tailored to your specific situation. If you begin inputting information about your situation and asking AI to create complex projections about your retirement plan, the chance of a mistake increases dramatically.

AI may also fail to incorporate assumptions about inflation or potential investment growth, meaning the projections and recommendations could be inaccurate and inappropriate for your unique situation.

This is why AI might be a useful resource for learning basic technical information about how pensions work and the options you have, but you should be cautious when asking it to support decision-making.

Get to know your pension with ZIO

When making changes to your retirement strategy, the ZIO app should be your first port of call.

Unlike AI, it provides clear information about your unique situation and helps you build a retirement plan from the ground up.

The Retirement Planner function allows you to input information about your current position, planned retirement age, and lifestyle expectations. It will then create projections – incorporating inflation and investment growth estimates – giving you a picture of what your pension pot could look like in the future.

Watch our video on the basics of the Retirement Planner tool to learn more.

The ZIO app and the Retirement Planner function provide, reliable information about your current and future position.

Get in touch

You can email pensions@rfsl.co.uk to learn more about our services today. Alternatively, call 01534 502000 in Jersey or 01481 747940 in Guernsey to discuss how we could support you.

Please note

This article is for general information only and does not constitute advice. The information is aimed at individuals only.

All information is correct at the time of writing and is subject to change in the future.

A pension is a long-term investment not normally accessible until 50.

The fund value may fluctuate and can go down, which would have an impact on the level of pension benefits available. Past performance is not a reliable indicator of future performance.

The tax implications of pension withdrawals will be based on your individual circumstances. Thresholds, percentage rates, and tax legislation may change.

Rossborough Financial Services Limited is regulated by the Jersey Financial Services Commission under the Financial Services (Jersey) Law 1998 and licensed by the Guernsey Financial Services Commission.

News and insights

Explore our articles, guides, videos and insights covering saving, investing, retirement planning and market news, designed to help you stay informed and make better financial decisions.

Show me all insights
Starting the pension conversation early: Why it matters and what we cover

19 November 2026

Starting the pension conversation early: Why it matters...

How to support employees in the 5 years before retirement

19 November 2026

How to support employees in the 5 years...

Marking Remembrance Day, in support of the Royal British Legion’s Poppy Appeal

19 November 2026

Marking Remembrance Day, in support of the Royal...

Could AI lead you to the wrong pension decision?

19 November 2026

Could AI lead you to the wrong pension...

Maximise your pension savings using Additional Voluntary Contributions

19 November 2026

Maximise your pension savings using Additional Voluntary Contributions

Are you on track for the retirement you want?

19 November 2026

Are you on track for the retirement you...

The important benefits of investing your employees may overlook

19 September 2026

The important benefits of investing your employees may...

3 reasons employees opt out of their pension and how to stop them

19 September 2026

3 reasons employees opt out of their pension...

Private medical insurance in retirement: 4 important factors to consider

19 September 2026

Private medical insurance in retirement: 4 important factors...

Is your family prepared for the Great Wealth Transfer?

19 September 2026

Is your family prepared for the Great Wealth...

Guide: How to plan for a 100-year life

19 September 2026

Guide: How to plan for a 100-year life

Time to tidy up your pensions? 4 steps to getting ready for retirement

19 September 2026

Time to tidy up your pensions? 4 steps...

The Nvidia moment: When overall market growth is driven by a small number of companies

19 August 2026

The Nvidia moment: When overall market growth is...

What is fiscal drag and how could it affect your finances?

19 August 2026

What is fiscal drag and how could it...

5 ways to engage Gen Z with their workplace pensions

19 August 2026

5 ways to engage Gen Z with their...

Why a pension and financial wellbeing presentation is important for your employees

19 August 2026

Why a pension and financial wellbeing presentation is...

The top 3 things to do with your pension now

19 August 2026

The top 3 things to do with your...

The gender pension gap and how you can close it

19 July 2026

The gender pension gap and how you can...

What is payroll saving and why is it catching on?

19 July 2026

What is payroll saving and why is it...

The most important workplace benefits ranked by employees

19 July 2026

The most important workplace benefits ranked by employees

5 budgeting tips to help you build the financial planning pyramid

19 June 2026

5 budgeting tips to help you build the...

Do you really need £64,800 a year to retire in the Channel Islands?

19 June 2026

Do you really need £64,800 a year to...

Everything you need to know about the State Pension

19 June 2026

Everything you need to know about the State...

3 common pitfalls to avoid when searching for a new savings account

19 June 2026

3 common pitfalls to avoid when searching for...

5 important details your employees need to know about their pensions

19 June 2026

5 important details your employees need to know...

How to make employee financial wellbeing a core part of your business

19 June 2026

How to make employee financial wellbeing a core...

Your complete guide to financial protection

16 June 2026

Your complete guide to financial protection

Financial protection is an important part of creating long-term security. Yet,...
What does BlackRock do?

9 June 2026

What does BlackRock do?

BlackRock is an asset manager and provides investment, advisory and risk...
What are asset classes?

9 June 2026

What are asset classes?

This episode of #BlackRockBasics covers what asset classes are, how they’re...
Does time in the market beat timing the market?

9 June 2026

Does time in the market beat timing the...

Watch to learn all about the two very similar-sounding but very...
Protect the foundations: what could knock your financial pyramid over?

19 May 2026

Protect the foundations: what could knock your financial...

3 historical events and how global stock markets reacted to them

19 May 2026

3 historical events and how global stock markets...

How regular investing could help you balance risk through “pound cost averaging”

19 May 2026

How regular investing could help you balance risk...

Why “time in the market” is more important than “timing the market”

19 May 2026

Why “time in the market” is more important...

Why your employees may be unprepared for retirement and how you could help

19 May 2026

Why your employees may be unprepared for retirement...

The surprising cost of serious illness for employers and employees

19 May 2026

The surprising cost of serious illness for employers...

5 important questions to answer if you’re jointly buying a home

29 April 2026

5 important questions to answer if you’re jointly...

Buying a new home with someone is exciting, and answering these...
Balancing your goals: How to manage your medium-term goals

28 April 2026

Balancing your goals: How to manage your medium-term...

It can be easy to overlook medium-term goals when reviewing long-term...
How to manage lifestyle inflation to keep your long-term goals on track

28 April 2026

How to manage lifestyle inflation to keep your...

Like inflation, lifestyle inflation could affect your finances, and you might...
Guide: 5 essential steps to plan for a pension shortfall if you want to retire early

28 April 2026

Guide: 5 essential steps to plan for a...

Getting the most out of your retirement and reaching your goals...
Guide – SMART goals: 5 steps to effective financial planning

30 March 2026

Guide – SMART goals: 5 steps to effective...

Planning your finances without clear goals could mean you miss the...